The 4% Rule Retirement is Failing Retirees — Here’s What Most Advisors Won’t Tell You
- Next Gen Wealth Journal

- Jul 7
- 4 min read
Is “Just Getting By” Really the Retirement You Dreamed Of?

Let me ask you honestly…
You’ve spent decades working hard, saving, sacrificing, doing everything “right.”
But when it’s finally your turn to enjoy life, they hit you with this advice:
“Just withdraw 4% a year — you’ll be fine.”
Sounds simple enough… but can I ask:
Is “fine” really the goal?
Or do you want to actually live the retirement you worked so hard for?
Before we settle for outdated advice, let’s dig into where this 4% rule came from — and why it might not be the safety net you think it is.
The 4% Rule retirement: Where It Came From (And Why It May Be Broken)
Back in the 1990s, financial planner William Bengen crunched the numbers to answer a critical question:
“How much can retirees safely withdraw each year — without running out of money?”
His research, based on historical stock and bond returns (even factoring in events like the Great Depression), showed that withdrawing 4% per year, adjusted for inflation, gave most retirees a good shot at making their money last 30 years.
It worked… back then.
But let’s be real:
Does the math from 30 years ago still apply to today’s unpredictable markets, longer lifespans, and rising costs?
If you’ve ever wondered that — you’re not alone.
Why Advisors Still Push the 4% Rule (Even If It’s Outdated)

On paper, the 4% rule sounds reasonable:
✔ Withdraw 4%
✔ Stay invested
✔ Supposedly “sleep easy”
But here’s the uncomfortable question most people never ask:
Who does the 4% rule really protect — you, or your advisor?
Think about it:
When your money stays locked in market-based accounts (stocks, bonds, mutual funds), you’re exposed to constant volatility.
And if the market crashes early in your retirement?
It’s not just a rough patch — it can derail your entire future.
Here’s the kicker:
By promoting the 4% rule, many advisors:
• Keep your funds under their management
• Limit the risk of you running out
• Lower the chances they get blamed if your portfolio tanks
So… is the 4% rule designed to help you thrive — or just to avoid disaster headlines?
If you’re aiming for more than “barely scraping by,” it’s worth questioning.
What Happens If You Withdraw More Than 4%?

Let’s flip the script for a second.
What if you decide:
“I didn’t save for 30+ years just to survive — I want to actually enjoy life.”
You increase your withdrawals to 6%, maybe 7% — seems reasonable, right?
But then… the market drops. Like in 2008. Or 2020. Or 2022.
Here’s how that plays out:
• You retire with $1,000,000
• Year one, the market tanks 20%
• Your balance shrinks to $800,000
• But you still withdraw $48,000 (6%)
• Now, you’re down to $752,000 — after just one year
Even if the market rebounds, that early damage is locked in. Every withdrawal chips away faster.
This is called sequence of returns risk — and it’s one of the fastest ways to drain your savings.
Hard truth: You could easily outlive your money.
Let me ask — is that the kind of retirement you envisioned?
There’s a Smarter Way to Retire Confidently
Here’s the good news — you’re not stuck playing defense.
What if you could:
• Enjoy your retirement
• Shield yourself from market crashes
• Have income that lasts — no matter how long you live
That’s where protected strategies come in.
By reallocating some of your assets into options like:
✅ Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs)
✅ Indexed Universal Life Insurance (IULs)
You can:
✔ Eliminate market downside risk
✔ Potentially withdraw more than 4%
✔ Create guaranteed lifetime income streams
✔ Access living benefits that traditional accounts can’t match
These aren’t fringe ideas — they’re safeguards for your future.
Question for you:
If you could grow your money during good years and protect it during downturns — wouldn’t it make sense to explore that?
The 4% Rule Was for the Old Economy — Are You Ready for Today?
To be clear: The 4% rule was smart for its time.
But times have changed:
• We live longer
• Markets swing harder
• Healthcare and living costs keep rising
• Taxes? Who knows where they’re headed
Outdated rules won’t cut it in today’s reality.
If you want to thrive — travel, enjoy your family, give generously, actually feel free — it takes more than hope.
You deserve certainty.
Final Thought: Don’t Settle for “Surviving” Retirement
You didn’t pour decades of effort into your career just to:
• Count pennies
• Fear the next market dip
• Wonder if your savings will last
You worked to create a life worth living — and protecting.
The question now is:
Are you playing to survive — or playing to win?
You have options. Smarter strategies exist. It starts with getting informed.
Next Steps: Want to See How Others Are Retiring Smarter?
Most families stay exposed to market losses, taxes, inflation, or retirement shortfalls — not because they want to… but because no one laid out simple, clear options for them.
Would it make sense to have a quick conversation — just to see how others are protecting their future, building tax-free wealth, and ensuring their families are covered?
➡️ [Book Your Free, No-Pressure Call]
Next Gen Wealth Journal
Protect. Grow. Pass It On.
Unlike the Other Guys Who Gamble — We Secure.



Comments